EYE IN THE SKY Moving from Man to Machine: Changing Paradigm of Military Decision Making “Never tell a soldier that he does not know the cost of war.” Lt Gen Frank Benson, Eye in the sky The British thriller movie Eye in the Sky written by Guy Hibbert and directed by Gavin Hood is the story of how the moral, ethical and legal implications of drone warfare are tested when a simple capture could have deadly results. Colonel Katherine Powell (played by Helen Mirren) heads up a team who look to identify, follow and eventually capture a terrorist group comprising a British national and her Muslim husband. The British and American authorities are monitoring the group travelling within Kenya from their respective offices using some very sophisticated “flies” and actual moles on ground. Using a drone, they locate her going to a safe house with a young man, where to their surprise, the terrorists are preparing for a suicide attack. Based on this intel, Col Powell changes the mission to not just physical capture of AL-Hady but to sending in a hellfire missile to kill all present in the safe house. This decision is met with anxiety and apprehension by her superior, Lieutenant General Frank Benson (Alan Rickman) who sits with some Members of Parliament who have basically come to witness the capture. The change of plan finds all the civilian authorities passing the buck until it reaches the level of the British Foreign Secretary James Willett (Iain Glen). Her plan is further complicated by the inhibition shown by the American drone pilot Steve Watts (Aaron Paul) who declines to send in the missile while a little
girl remains within the casualty area. As the sides argue about the best move, their moral and legal obligations are tested. The action in the movie takes place at five different locales: Col Powell’s war room: the plan of action is being initiated from here American War room: The drone pilot, his superior and his support staff is here. They are the ones who will execute Col Powell’s plan Field Operatives : Young civilians and Armed military units who are helping Col Powell for physical and virtual interception of the safe house British Conference Room: Lt Gen Frank Benson, Col Powell’s superior and a member of the Defence Committee along with a legal expert and a Member of Parliament (also a lady) who are monitoring and giving an approval to Col Powell’s decisions on the Cabinet level. British Foreign Secretary’s office: Coordinates the efforts with their American counterparts. “We’ve got two suicide bombers inside that house but no one wants to take responsibility for pulling the trigger.” Colonel Katherine Powell This movie provides us with a short yet nerve-wrecking glimpse of how the future drone warfare requires quick, competitive yet compassionate decision-making from the military as well as civilian leadership. The movie echoes the question time and again “what makes a good kill in a pilot-less or more correctly called a Drone-led attack” through its
characters. For instance, we find the British Lt Gen (a man) and Colonel (a woman) working in tandem when it comes to quickly changing the aim of the mission from a capture to a kill while on ground, the American pilot (a man) who is their “Eye in the Sky” and his assistant a sergeant (woman) together worried about the well being of the little girl near the area of attack. The senior leadership demonstrates the conviction that goes on with the kind of mission that they are handling: to capture a highly volatile terrorist group. Equally capable are the middle –rank officers as in the pilots and the fighter controllers who got through the Standard Operating Procedures and necessary checks with complete dedication and integrity. “I am the pilot in command responsible for releasing this weapon. I will fire when this girl is out of the
way.”Steve Watts, the Pilot Although the fighter pilot is supposed to be the one with the Killer instinct, it is he who is shown to be full of mercy and compassion for that one human life while on the other hand, the Colonel with her assertion is too trying to kill the terrorists to deter a big human bomb explosion that they are planning. Unlike the compassionate Pilot and his assertive denial to press the “kill” button to his superiors; the Col goes on to strongly yet authoritatively influences her assistant: another Black to estimate the chances of the girl being killed as less than 50% so that she can give the order to kill the terrorists. This way she gets the American to press the “kill” button finally.
But surprisingly opposite to these military characters are the civilian bureaucracy members who play with their words and simply deny agreeing to convert the mission from capture to a kill. Despite, they being able to see all the efforts being taken by the military teams, starting from the local spies in field who even try to buy the little girl’s bread to persuade her to vanish from the scene; spy who plants a bug at the cost of getting caught by local military, which helps them to discover the big store of explosive vests and weapons inside the safe house and their American counterparts; they simply start questioning the legal, moral and military grounds on which such a decision to kill a young girl can be taken. “If they kill 80 people, we win the propaganda war. If we kill one child, they do.” After they try to argue on the legality of the mission, their
best façade of an argument created to deny the kill is what if such a video would be released in social media over a period of time? They are not worried about the terrorists moving out of the safe house with the explosive body vests on and enter a shopping mall and kill hundreds of civilian population. Their worry is how they can justify the kill of one British National (who has turned into a terrorist) if at all the news is leaked outside in the media. One can see the difference in the way their American counterparts think about the whole matter and are very clear about taking down the target even with the changed perspective keeping in mind the safety and security of the Nation as a whole. The
beauty of this movie also lies in how it keeps exploring the different layers in which the future warfare is going to be played and how all these different layers are interwoven with each other. The humans controlling the Net-centric warfare and their humane or otherwise attitudes as well as aptitudes play a decisive role in contemporary warfare. We find the Pilot controlling the drone so humane, unlike a video-gamer or a “killer”. Similarly, we find the civilian leadership blaming the military leadership of forcing them into homicide while they deny accepting their larger responsibility of deterring a “suicide-bomber” attack on civilian populations. While one nation’s leadership is very clear about using power to stop the terrorists, the other nation is still fussing over the legality and moralities of kills. To sum it up, I would only say that the movie shows very clearly the difference in aims of the military leadership who calculate their
each decision minutely and stand to experience its actual effects in life while their civilian counterparts are only concerned about hypothetical diplomatic crisis. The movie’s importance once again, is not as just an excellent piece of art but also an excellent tool to understand the whole process of decision-making in a net-centric warfare. I can’t stop myself from once again quoting the very assertive Colonel Powell: The aim of this exercise would be “Obvious to Anyone Not Trying to Avoid Making a Decision”. P.S. I am happy to share that the website has featured as one of the “Top 10 Indian defence blogs” A big thanks to Webocto and Anuj Agarwal @Feedspot HTTPS://blog.feedspot.com/indian_defence_blogs/
Howdy! I simply would like to give you a big thumbs up for your great info you have got here on this post. I am coming back to your web site for more soon. Marchelle Wally Brottman
Massa suspendisse lorem turpis ac. Pellentesque volutpat faucibus pellentesque velit in, leo odio molestie, magnis vitae condimentum. Feodora Wolfgang Ibbie
Curabitur sit amet mauris. Morbi in dui quis est pulvinar ullamcorper. Nulla facilisi. Integer lacinia sollicitudin massa. Cras metus. Rona Griffin Jodee
discrete viagra online paypal australia buy generic viagra no prior prescription required pharmacy
cialis for sale brand cialis debit card buy cialis australia
quick tabs viagra buy viagra with paypal indian version for viagra
cheap prescription drugs canada pharmacy online orders canadian pharmacies
canadian pills best online pharmacy stores order medicine online
best 10 online canadian pharmacies skin care canadian pharmacy reviews
cialis online pharmacy cheap viagra 100mg canada drugs online
online pharmacies in usa vardenafil pharmacy cheap no prescription
canadian drugstore the canadian pharmacy vardenafil
buy brand name viagra online viagra over night viagra cialis levitra sample pack
A wonderful serenity has taken possession of my entire soul, like these sweet mornings of spring which I enjoy with my whole heart. I am alone, and feel the charm of existence in this spot, which was created for the bliss of souls like mine. I am so happy, my dear friend, so absorbed in the exquisite sense of mere tranquil. Gisella Calvin Montagu
I really like and appreciate your article post. Really thank you! Really Great. Heath Alvan Wheaton
Hello there. I found your website via Google while searching for a comparable matter, your website came up. It seems great. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks to come back then. Risa Sal Bille
Everyone loves it when folks get together and share ideas. Great site, continue the good work! Charlean Arther Lauren
I was able to find good advice from your blog articles. Mag Thorpe Oliver
Your photo evokes the magic of winter. I believe the human spirit is very resilient. Adriaens Sinclair Fiann
Hi there. I discovered your site by the use of Google at the same time as looking for a comparable topic, your website came up. It looks good. I have bookmarked it in my google bookmarks to come back then. Nissie Nevil Winchester
A second nested comment; Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Quos nisi redarguimus, omnis virtus, omne decus, omnis vera laus deserenda est. Sullae consulatum? Multoque hoc melius nos veriusque quam Stoici. Scisse enim te quis coarguere possit? Eam tum adesse, cum dolor omnis absit; Ad corpus diceres pertinere-, sed ea, quae dixi, ad corpusne refers? Madlin Elijah Heidie
viagra at tesco online viagra light switch plate purchase viagra with paypal
After all, we should remember compellingly reintermediate mission-critical potentialities whereas cross functional scenarios. Phosfluorescently re-engineer distributed processes without standardized supply chains. Quickly initiate efficient initiatives without wireless web services. Interactively underwhelm turnkey initiatives before high-payoff relationships. Holisticly restore superior interfaces before flexible technology. Donni Langsdon Roderigo
Yes you are correct, truly PHP is a open source and its help we can take free from any community or website since it happens here at this web site. Chrystel Neall Winonah
I go to see day-to-day some websites and websites to read content, but this web site gives quality based writing. Mindy Sterne Rosalinde
A motivating discussion is worth comment. I think that you should publish more about this subject, it may not be a taboo matter but generally people do not speak about these topics. To the next! Kind regards! Tilda Nilson Duncan
Wow, what a quality it is! Since mostly YouTube video lessons have no pleasant feature, except this is in fact a pleasant quality video. Engracia Rickey Maressa
Very nice cake. I used raisins as the optional dried fruit. Used spelt and all purpose flours and reduced sugar a little. Great texture and flavour; will definitely make again. Ulrika Zolly Rodolphe
Hi, just wanted to say, I enjoyed this post. It was practical. Emlynne Emmerich Delanos
cash advance avgift bad credit money loans what happens if you can’t pay a payday loan back
payday loan post falls idaho best payday loan consolidation cash loan 100
payday loans low apr paperless cash loans fca payday loans
youtube cialis commercial viagra-cialis-kamagra.com cialis order in canada
citalopram und cialis cialis viagra buy online where can u buy cialis
I was just searching for this info for a while. After six hours of continuous Googleing, finally I got it in your site. I wonder what is the lack of Google strategy that do not rank this kind of informative sites in top of the list. Normally the top websites are full of garbage. Goldie Taddeo Alarise
usually posts some pretty interesting stuff like this. If youre new to this site Milly Cleveland Aridatha
Crud much unstinting violently pessimistically far camel inanimately a remade dove disagreed hellish one concisely before with this erotic frivolous. Willyt Randolf Rutherford
calculating annual interest rate on payday loan citibank ready credit cash advance payday loans in macon ga
Heya i am for the first time here. I found this board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and help others like you helped me. Leia Ezequiel Kary
cnch6 yegip fyfa