• About
Friday, April 16, 2021
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
NEWSLETTER
Lifeskills
  • Home
  • About
  • ELT
  • Food
  • IAF
  • Life & Travel
  • Military Intelligence
  • Entertainment
  • Parenting
  • Soft Skills
  • Women in Armed Forces
  • Sports
  • Home
  • About
  • ELT
  • Food
  • IAF
  • Life & Travel
  • Military Intelligence
  • Entertainment
  • Parenting
  • Soft Skills
  • Women in Armed Forces
  • Sports
No Result
View All Result
Lifeskills
No Result
View All Result
Home Entertainment

Glamour and Guts: THE TEST CASE

by Sqn Ldr Vidula Abhyankar Retd
September 3, 2020
in Entertainment
82
Glamour and Guts: THE TEST CASE
0
SHARES
77
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

 Induction of Women in Special Forces in Indian Armed Forces 
Prologue
Women’s’ role in the Indian army can be traced back to as early as 1888 when the “Indian Military Nursing Service” was formed during the reign of the British Raj. It was only in 1992 that the Indian army decided to induct females to serve in combat units like the Infantry, the Armoured Corps, and Mechanised Infantry. To their credit, both the government of India and the defense ministry have finalised their plans for setting up a permanent commission for women officers in law and education and naval constructors’ branch. While a set of policies concerning the grant of permanent commission to women officers in certain branches of the Indian Air Force have been issued, the Indian Army is yet to issue any similar policies. As of 2018, women have yet not been allowed as combatants in the combat specialist forces, such as Ghatak, Garud, MARCOS, para-commandos. Current policy also takes from them the right to be inducted into arms of the Indian Army which involve a direct combat role.
Web Series: The Test Case (2017)

Directed by Vinay Waikul and Nagesh Kukunoor, The Test Case is a fictionalised account of Indian Army’s first woman officer undergoing the Special Forces training in Indian Army. Captain Shikha Sharma is considered to be a “test case” by the first Indian woman defence minister for being inducted as a commando in Indian Army. As expected this creates a big furor in the lives of all related to the Special Forces Training School, starting from the top brass in Army headquarters to the Special staff such as a Lady Medical Officer, her Ustads, the course mates and the Commanding Officer of the training establishment. With the likes of Nimrat Kaur, Juhi Chawla, Akshay Oberoi, Atul Kulkarni, Rahul Dev and Sumit Suri in key roles, for a change Balaji Productions and Ekta Kapoor tried to create a nearly perfect patriotic-watch for the weekend. The 9 episodes web series is available on Netflix and is worth a one-time watch for all Indian Army lovers.

Media Reviews:
The show became famous for all the wrong reasons due to the exit of Nagesh Kukunoor in the post –production phase due to certain creative differences between Ekta and him. Many criticized the show for its over-dramatised scenes, esp in the first episode; the personalized vindictive end; disturbing background score and leaving loose ends in characterizations. Critics still praised Ekta Kapoor and her team for her experimental beginning, the realistic direction and gritty screenplay; and of course, composed performances by all the actors. 
Military Reviews:
Since there are only a few worthwhile military reviews available on net about the series; I take this opportunity to present my views as a combatant and a common woman about the show. The series does become significant for today’s youth who would want to join the Armed forces in any capacity for it succeeds in portrayal of certain inherent issues bothering Indian Army for past few decades,such as:  
the working environment of a Special Forces Establishment, camaraderie between NDA course mates; differences between the Direct Entry officers and the NDA trained officers;
the ease enjoyed by second generation officers under units commanded by their parents; the regimental superiority within few army units; and the cultural mind block of the superiors as well as subordinates in accepting and addressing woman officers
These have been subtly shown in the very first episode. Although the director and writers have taken certain creative liberties throughout the series, they succeed in presenting the main idea in an impressive way. Jumping to save another brother officer in the very first week at the unit; sharing the same bathing area and dormitory with the gentlemen officers; the ultimate sexual assault and handling of the indiscipline case in a melodramatic way in front of all are just a few of them. Also, the rising tendency of officers and other ranks indulging in writing anonymous letters about cases of injustice rather than using the existing honourable procedures and espirit-de-corps being forgotten for personal benefits and promotions has been amply portrayed in some of the main characters. A military way out instead of a personalized solution of the problem would have definitely enhanced the overall universal appeal of the series.
 Women in Special Forces Worldwide

There are roughly a dozen nations that have opened “close combat roles” to women as discussed before. Some of these countries have taken “three to ten years to go through this process, to integrate women” into combat roles. In many parts of the world, these efforts have moved quickly once they’ve begun.

1.      In 1985, Norway became the first country in NATO to allow women to serve in all combat capacities, including submarines. Norwegian women are also subject to the draft in the event of a national mobilization.
2.      Women have been able to serve in all defense units, including infantry and artillery units, since New Zealand too passed a law to that effect in 2001.
3.       In 1989 Canada opened all combat roles except those involving submarine warfare to women. In 2000, women were given the green light to serve on subs as well.
4.      Since 1988, Denmark has had a policy of “total inclusion,” which came on the heels of 1985 “combat trials” exploring the capabilities of women to fight on the front lines. Danish research showed that women performed just as well as men in land combat roles.
5.      Women make up nearly one-fifth of the French military and can serve in all posts except on submarines and in the riot-control gendarmerie. Though permitted to serve in the combat infantry, however, most chose not to.
6.      In 2001, the country opened German combat units to women, dramatically increasing the recruitment of female soldiers into the ranks. The number of women in the German Armed Forces is now three times as high as in 2001.
7.      In 1985 the Israeli Defense Force (IDF) began putting women into combat positions and by 2009 women were serving in artillery units, rescue forces, and in anti-aircraft forces.
8.      In addition to the U.S., Australia is another country to most recently remove barriers to its front-line units, provided women meet the physical requirements. In 2011, Australia’s defense minister announced that the last 7 percent of positions that had been closed to women—including Special Forces, infantry, and artillery—would be opened up to them.
Arguments against utility of women in  Worldwide Special Forces
1.          The military will be forced to lower or compromise its current standards to accommodate the new gender parity. This lowering/compromise of the standards will have an adverse effect on mission accomplishment, lower unit cohesion and erode esprit de corps.
2.          Special Operations units when deployed operate in austere environments. Many times the facilities given for units to live and operate in are small and very cramped. Separate bathroom and living quarters may not be available and living in close proximity to women will have an adverse effect on the unit.
3.          The Special Forces teams are like a family. There is very little disparity based on ranks and mutual respect is commonly based on each other’s physical and leadership skills. In such cases, there is a tremendous amount of trust placed on each other to accomplish their mission. Putting women in such tight situations in such units would mean letting in distrust and preference between the members.
4.          Integrating women into Special Forces units would erode unit cohesion as there will be a double/separate standard set up for female combatants due to lack of similar infrastructure existing in Indian special forces units/establishments.
5.          The men would not have confidence in the woman’s leadership abilities and most importantly there would be a lack of trust in their ability to uphold an equal share in watching each other’s back in real time combat operations.
6.          Women are demonstrably weaker, more breakable, have drastically less lung capacity, and even shoot less accurately. Thus their performances in combat operations would not be up to the mark.
7.          Even if women manage to meet the laid down standards, they would be more likely to be disabled than their male counterparts and to receive a physical disability discharge for severe

        physical disorder. They’re more likely to suffer stress fractures and other disabilities related to combat.

8.          Besides the physical aspects of the job, women will have to battle cultural prejudices that exist in many rural parts of the country where women warriors are not a common sight. In many of the states where our Special Forces now operate (remote parts of Chattisgarh, Rajasthan and J&K), women are kept separate from men and women leaders would never be accepted.
9.          Special Operations by Special Forces are generally conducted in deep dense forests in cross-border areas. The strongest argument against use of women in such situations still remains to be the detrimental Post Operation Trauma: social, emotional and physical in case if any woman operator is left behind as a POW. The chances of her being sexually assaulted, tortured or the worst impregnated cannot be denied.
10.       The shelf life of any well-performing gentleman MARCO ranges from 05 -07 years. In case of women, due to the societal Indian customs would be reduced to 03-05 years; which would be too less as compared to the amount of training, man hours and finances invested in them.
Pertinent issues related to Women in Forces in Indian Armed Forces
“You were so preoccupied with whether or not you could that you didn’t stop to think if they should.”Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park
Somewhat similar to the disturbance caused by genetic rebirth of the dinosaurs in the Hollywood series Jurassic Park; the Indian government has caused an unwanted chaos which would be disturbing both for the Army as well as the women. Although the Armies world over might have started to induct women in branches such as Artillery or Infantry, they have still limited the role of women in Special Forces to areas such as internal security, surveillance and/or intelligence.
Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Joseph Dunford, a Marine general with several tours of duty in the Iraq War and Afghanistan presented an internal Marine Corps study in 2015 with evidence that women suffered drawbacks not only in the more obvious areas involving strength and stamina, but were more likely to get injured in training and were much less capable of hitting a target.
In 2012, when the issue wasn’t even special ops but just women in combat, Marine Capt. Katie Petronio published a powerful essay entitled, “Get Over it; We Are Not All Created Equal.” She knew what she was talking about: Her body was broken by two combat deployments. Due to the time she spent in full combat load, she suffered numerous nerve damage and physical problems.
Keeping such experiences in mind, utility of women in actual combat in a cross-border conflict in the Indian sub-continent would depend on answers to basically three questions. 
     1.      With the kind of Jihadi combat operations going on worldwide, is this really the time to begin inducting women in such highly specialized jobs?
      2.      Is our Army really ready to take them? Putting women in a traditionally male-dominated area such as Special Operations is going to be tough for considering the cultural block in their male counterparts and the lack of infrastructure required for them.
    3.      And finally, will the Indian Army be stronger as a result of including women in Special Operations? 
 Conclusion 
“I have to be clear: You have to meet the physical standards, because the job is still the same. It works very well as long as women hold the standards. It’s not a big deal because women who go into these fields know the standards, and it’s not that hard for women to train up to the standards if they really want.” 
said Colonel Gjerde, an infantry officer and the commander of Norwegian forces in Afghanistan in 2012. 
A study on the integration of female combatants in the IDF between 2002 and 2005 found that women often exhibit “superior skills” in discipline, motivation, and shooting abilities, yet still face prejudicial treatment stemming from “a perceived threat to the historical male combat identity.” The accuracy of support weapons such as aircraft and artillery has improved, but battles are still decided by the grit and competency of the people on the ground. And both actual combat and the experience of combat conditions have actually become more difficult since Vietnam because of one simple factor –will power. Both men and women with great physical standards can survive or succumb in extremely stressful situations, provided they will. Hence, the biological limitations might be just one aspect of the whole argument about induction of women in Special Forces in Indian Army.
Recommendations
“War is not a Nintendo game.”
-Commanding General H. Norman Schwarzkopf declared in the 1991 Gulf War

Inducting the women in Special Forces for winning the Lok Sabha Elections and then limiting the
role of such women to ceremonial duties and VIP security would be cheating the Indian Army and the Indian masses, in general. Hence, in order to make the whole change worthwhile, certain recommendations need to be considered prior to taking the new step would be:

      1.      To conduct a real-time Needs Analysis and Readiness for the induction of women in SF.
      2.      To clearly outline the role that would be played by the newly enrolled women.
      3.      To culturally, mentally and physically prepare the male counterparts about the induction.
    4.  To create appropriate training environment for the women trainees to handle close-combat situations.
Sqn Ldr Vidula Abhyankar Retd

Sqn Ldr Vidula Abhyankar Retd

Next Post
Easy Recipes for Healthy Weight Gain in Babies, Toddlers and Kids

Easy Recipes for Healthy Weight Gain in Babies, Toddlers and Kids

Comments 82

  1. cheap tofranil says:
    3 months ago

    My husband and i ended up being absolutely delighted Chris could carry out his analysis because of the ideas he acquired from your blog. It’s not at all simplistic just to always be freely giving concepts a number of people could have been making money from. And now we acknowledge we’ve got the blog owner to appreciate because of that. All of the explanations you’ve made, the easy blog menu, the friendships you aid to create – it’s all amazing, and it’s aiding our son and our family believe that that article is amusing, and that’s especially essential. Many thanks for all!

    Reply
  2. hair loss drugs over the counter for sale says:
    2 months ago

    Hello. magnificent job. I did not imagine this. This is a impressive story. Thanks! https://hairlossbimedi.com hair loss drugs over the counter for sale

    Reply
  3. JudeKHerdt says:
    2 months ago

    Hi there, You’ve done an excellent job.
    I’ll certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends.
    I’m sure they will be benefited from this web site.

    my web blog … JudeKHerdt

    Reply
  4. Wesleyobels says:
    1 month ago

    buy tadalafil us generic tadalafil
    40 mg tadalafil

    Reply
  5. RandyFup says:
    1 month ago

    meds without a doctor prescription best online international pharmacies india

    Reply
  6. MichaelPhake says:
    1 month ago

    medications without a doctor’s prescription generic pills

    Reply
  7. RandyFup says:
    1 month ago

    generic drugs without doctor’s prescription: https://genericwdp.com/ buy prescription drugs online without

    Reply
  8. MichaelPhake says:
    1 month ago

    india pharmacy drugs: https://genericwdp.com/ buy cheap prescription drugs online

    Reply
  9. WaynePaurE says:
    1 month ago

    when will viagra be generic viagra without a doctor prescription usa
    cheap viagra online

    Reply
  10. WaynePaurE says:
    1 month ago

    cost of viagra where to buy viagra
    how much is viagra

    Reply
  11. JeffreyWex says:
    1 month ago

    viagra without a doctor prescription usa buy real viagra online
    where can i buy viagra over the counter

    Reply
  12. WaynePaurE says:
    1 month ago

    how much is viagra where to buy viagra online
    viagra over the counter

    Reply
  13. JeffreyWex says:
    1 month ago

    viagra price viagra from india
    viagra price

    Reply
  14. WaynePaurE says:
    1 month ago

    order viagra online buy viagra online usa
    where to buy viagra online

    Reply
  15. JeffreyWex says:
    1 month ago

    viagra from canada viagra over the counter
    online doctor prescription for viagra

    Reply
  16. WaynePaurE says:
    1 month ago

    viagra over the counter 100mg viagra
    viagra online usa

    Reply
  17. JeffreyWex says:
    1 month ago

    100mg viagra viagra amazon
    buy viagra online canada

    Reply
  18. RicardoNow says:
    1 month ago

    zithromax online usa no prescription zithromax 250 price
    over the counter ed treatment

    Reply
  19. StanleyNow says:
    1 month ago

    fincar buy propecia online cheap

    Reply
  20. RicardoNow says:
    4 weeks ago

    diflucan prescription australia diflucan 200 mg price
    ed treatment drugs

    Reply
  21. StanleyNow says:
    4 weeks ago

    generic paxil 20 mg paxil

    Reply
  22. RicardoNow says:
    4 weeks ago

    order viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ where to buy viagra

    Reply
  23. Rsauxd says:
    4 weeks ago

    buy tadalafil online reddit – tadalafila 5mg ache preГ§o generic tadalafil 20mg

    Reply
  24. RicardoNow says:
    4 weeks ago

    buy real viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ best place to buy generic viagra online

    Reply
  25. ThomasonTor says:
    4 weeks ago

    viagra price https://viagrapills100.com/ generic viagra walmart

    Reply
  26. RicardoNow says:
    4 weeks ago

    buy generic 100mg viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ price of viagra

    Reply
  27. ThomasonTor says:
    4 weeks ago

    best place to buy generic viagra online https://viagrapills100.com/ viagra 100mg price

    Reply
  28. Marvinsog says:
    4 weeks ago

    buy ed drugs erectyle disfunction
    buy ed pills from canada

    Reply
  29. Elmerfuems says:
    3 weeks ago

    buy ed pills ed pills without a doctor prescription
    cheap ed pills from canada

    Reply
  30. Marvinsog says:
    3 weeks ago

    natural ed pills cheap ed pills from canada
    ed meds online without doctor prescription

    Reply
  31. Pqalxb says:
    3 weeks ago

    Pecjqw – provigil schedule Ynekub fqmguv

    Reply
  32. Elmerfuems says:
    3 weeks ago

    cheap ed pills from canada natural help for ed
    ed medication online

    Reply
  33. Qujloh says:
    3 weeks ago

    Doadkl – cialis walmart Laoslf rrrlqd

    Reply
  34. Fidzid says:
    3 weeks ago

    Irfavk – furosempi.com Ylgedp etillb

    Reply
  35. Marvinsog says:
    3 weeks ago

    prednisone 5 mg tablet cost: buy prednisone online – how can i order prednisone

    Reply
  36. JasonKal says:
    3 weeks ago

    https://prednisonest.com/# how much is prednisone 10mg

    Reply
  37. Marvinsog says:
    3 weeks ago

    zithromax: cheap zithromax – generic zithromax 500mg india

    Reply
  38. JasonKal says:
    3 weeks ago

    https://gabapentinst.com/# neurontin brand name 800mg best price

    Reply
  39. Cuvmyb says:
    3 weeks ago

    Svvdhb – tetracycls.com Bfotts kwdpdn

    Reply
  40. Marvinsog says:
    3 weeks ago

    plaquenil price canada: buy plaquenil 0.5 – best price for plaquenil

    Reply
  41. Jbnyud says:
    3 weeks ago

    Ksnbbz – cialis 60 mg price Aaqnfq baosvq

    Reply
  42. Marvinsog says:
    3 weeks ago

    plaquenil 75 mg: buy hydroxychloroquine online – plaquenil tabs

    Reply
  43. Dkjvzn says:
    2 weeks ago

    Ksjwmg – canadian pharmacy viagra 200mg Yplqdx kanirp

    Reply
  44. Victoroxics says:
    2 weeks ago

    http://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax 250 mg tablet price
    zithromax cost

    Reply
  45. Scottnuh says:
    2 weeks ago

    http://zithromaxproff.com/# zithromax 500 tablet
    buy zithromax 1000mg online

    Reply
  46. Victoroxics says:
    2 weeks ago

    https://zithromaxproff.com/# buy zithromax 1000 mg online
    buy zithromax no prescription

    Reply
  47. Lphwym says:
    2 weeks ago

    Ijtkpk – essay writing difficulties Mvnzzo sydnpo

    Reply
  48. Scottnuh says:
    2 weeks ago

    http://zithromaxproff.com/# where can i purchase zithromax online
    order zithromax without prescription

    Reply
  49. Qzsskd says:
    2 weeks ago

    Hoaqys – generic viagra 2017 Gskaxq wwreat

    Reply
  50. FrankTer says:
    2 weeks ago

    order sumycin: noroxin price
    trimox online

    Reply
  51. Scottnuh says:
    2 weeks ago

    order augmentin: buy minomycin
    fucidin capsules

    Reply
  52. FrankTer says:
    2 weeks ago

    buy zyvox online: fucidin generic
    order keftab online

    Reply
  53. Niielx says:
    2 weeks ago

    Hlrjpd – personal statement help Orrqdz hqrikl

    Reply
  54. Scottnuh says:
    2 weeks ago

    cephalexin online: stromectol generic
    ampicillin price

    Reply
  55. Gaxsvs says:
    2 weeks ago

    Dpdoxl – walgreens propecia generic Xxqqhn xoxhqq

    Reply
  56. CharlesHal says:
    2 weeks ago

    online indian pharmacies: online indian pharmacies prescriptions from india

    Reply
  57. StevenBaity says:
    2 weeks ago

    order prescription drugs from india: trusted india online pharmacies united pharmacy india

    Reply
  58. Xukgqm says:
    1 week ago

    Eqjsrj – viagra side effects forum Kdhoyb ztnyll

    Reply
  59. CharlesHal says:
    1 week ago

    buy prescriptions from india pharmacy: online indian pharmacies all generic meds from india

    Reply
  60. StevenBaity says:
    1 week ago

    india pharmacy drugs: india pharmacies shipping to usa india pharmacy mail order

    Reply
  61. Ugwget says:
    1 week ago

    Spmesg – buy finasteride 5mg online uk Lgbhdq pbtanf

    Reply
  62. Alfredgok says:
    1 week ago

    order erectile dysfunction pills: mail order erectile dysfunction pills ed pills for sale

    Reply
  63. BillyKet says:
    1 week ago

    order erectile dysfunction pills online: ed pills viagra pills

    Reply
  64. Danilotib says:
    1 week ago

    free adult chat sites
    milfs dating.com

    Reply
  65. Alfredgok says:
    1 week ago

    erectile pills canada: best erectile dysfunction pills review cialis ed pills

    Reply
  66. Wucauh says:
    1 week ago

    Pzlvzp – college of charleston essay Vwnzwr sekysr

    Reply
  67. BillyKet says:
    7 days ago

    levitra pills: order erectile dysfunction pills best erectile dysfunction pills review

    Reply
  68. Harrydoche says:
    6 days ago

    viagra without prescription viagra without prescription viagra without prescription

    Reply
  69. Riwrqi says:
    6 days ago

    Fipvrw – sildenafil and amlodipine Npnmlg ujbnbb

    Reply
  70. TimothyIrrib says:
    5 days ago

    online dating sites
    local girla near me personals

    Reply
  71. JamesAssow says:
    5 days ago

    best place to buy viagra online non prescription viagra no prescription viagra

    Reply
  72. Harrydoche says:
    5 days ago

    cheap viagra 100mg viagra online without prescription viagra no prescription

    Reply
  73. TimothyIrrib says:
    4 days ago

    dating online
    dating personal ads

    Reply
  74. Bvesnp says:
    4 days ago

    Lglbjn – writing a persuasive speech Dliizp jenfjh

    Reply
  75. JamesAssow says:
    4 days ago

    buy generic viagra online viagra online without prescription buy viagra online without prescription

    Reply
  76. RobertoKnima says:
    2 days ago

    https://amoxilst.com/# amoxicillin cost australia

    Reply
  77. Xwkryo says:
    2 days ago

    Linycx – furosemidelasixx.com Cyyozd xvfeag

    Reply
  78. JamesAssow says:
    2 days ago

    http://clomidst.com/# clomid coupon

    Reply
  79. RobertoKnima says:
    1 day ago

    http://amoxilst.com/# amoxicillin pharmacy price

    Reply
  80. Cirudw says:
    22 hours ago

    Tqqggv – vardenafil side effects Ynljry nwviso

    Reply
  81. JamesAssow says:
    12 hours ago

    http://amoxilst.com/# amoxicillin script

    Reply
  82. RobertoKnima says:
    12 hours ago

    https://doxycyclinest.com/# where to get doxycycline

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

What do you know about Lord Ganesha?

What do you know about Lord Ganesha?

2 years ago
OF MICE AND KIDS

OF MICE AND KIDS

3 years ago

Popular News

  • Read your Baby

    Read your Baby

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Women in Armed Forces – Part III

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Importance of Group Testing at SSBs

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • How to get a job without being nervous in an interview

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Importance of Personal Interview in SSB

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Connect with us

Lifeskills
Sqn Ldr Vidula Abhyankar (retd) A SSC Officer of Indian Air Force, having background of a linguist in English Language (ELT) has worked for last 17 years in the field of education, training and development of Air warriors and their families.

Category

  • ELT
  • Entertainment
  • Food
  • IAF
  • Life and Travel
  • Military Intelligence
  • Others
  • Parenting
  • Soft Skills
  • Sports
  • Women in Armed Forces

Social Links

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instagram

Recent Posts

  • Thematic Apperception Test
  • SITUATION REACTION TEST
  • WORD ASSOCIATION TEST

© 2020 Lifeskills

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
  • ELT
  • Food
  • IAF
  • Life and Travel
  • Military Intelligence
  • Entertainment
  • Parenting
  • Soft Skills
  • Women in Armed Forces
  • Others

© 2020 Lifeskills

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In